Happy Ashtray
Weathervane
(Kitchen Sink Records)
Any double album will raise an eyebrow, but the fact that this 24 song opus is the work of one man leaves my head shaking. John Swamy under the Happy Ashtray moniker wrote, performed, and recorded the material last year, and rather than stagger out releases he let out a barrage in four parts over two discs. Overall Weathervane is long on ideas and thankfully matched in length by talent, but where the album comes up short is obviously the in editing department, as even well-played alt-pop needs room to breathe and move and dance without tripping over it’s own two dozen feet.
Points of reference are somewhat easily found, but only snippets at a time, as the melting pot of sounds gets stirred at a pretty even pace. You can hear some Beck in specific songs like “Mississippi,” but also his influence is felt in the sense that Swamy has similar chameleon-like characteristics, blending in with various genres as if by nature. Roots rock, folk pop, and indie jangle tracks all sound genuine and far from forced. A smoother John Fogerty mixed with a less-trippy Wayne Coyne will put you in the right vocal ballpark , but I wouldn’t really plug CCR or the Flaming Lips into the equation outright. There certainly is a sense of prolific-ness, and a few tracks sound like half-songs, but again the unabashed pop of Guided By Voices is a just a sliver in the overall sound. The college-radio friendliness of R.E.M., Van Morrisson’s blue-eyed soul (or possible a less deadpan Soul Coughing), and Uncle Tupelo’s twang-tinged rock all seem like points that will help orient a listener, but as it all gets deftly swirled around it simultaneously sounds like all of them and none of them.
The sprightly shuffle of “Cold So Cold” is a superb choice for an opener, the smoky groove of “Sold My Flavor On” is great, and the back porch pop of “Starlight” could’ve been big back during the alt-country boom. “100 Down” is a effective straight-ahead rocker, “His Mind Is Reeling” sounds like Elephant 6 fuzz pop/rock without the psychedelia or tounge-in-cheekness. “Solution” is nice and slinky, while “Set Alive” reaches near Atlantic R&B levels of soul rock. Disc highlight and shoulda-been-a-hit “Five Fingered Friend” (finally) appears at the last quarter of the album. It’s one of those catchy tunes that has a rock/pop melody that isn’t mined very often, so it’s got that hummable and fresh quality that makes for a classic mix tape song or radio smash. All aforementioned tracks already make a solid single album, but on top of these you’ve still got another 16 songs that lie somewhere amongst all descriptors for more enjoyable listening. It’s a big undertaking for both performer and audience, and in this day of cherry-picking mp3s instead of “sitting down with an album” it’s a bit risky to present this much material, but in the end I’ve got no complaints. It’s time well spent.
-- Mark Hughson
Happy Ashtray Web site | MySpace